- Jason Bateman Simon
- Rebecca Hall Robyn
- Joel Edgerton Gordo
- Allison Tolman Lucy
- Tim Griffin Kevin 'KK' Keelor
- Busy Philipps Duffy
- Wendell Pierce Detective Mills
- David Denman Frank Dale
- Susan May Pratt Rhonda Ryan
- P.J. Byrne Danny
- Beau Knapp Detective Walker
- Katie Aselton Joan
- David Joseph Craig Stewart
