- Justin Long Bartleby Gaines
- Blake Lively Monica
- Columbus Short Hands
- Jonah Hill Sherman
- Maria Thayer Rory
- Adam Herschman Glen
- Diora Baird Kiki
- Lewis Black Tío Ben
- Anthony Heald Decano Van Horne
- Mark Derwin Jack Gaines
- Travis Van Winkle Hoyt Ambrose
- Jeremy Howard Estudiante freaky
